*Updating Already*
So, now I chose to not have a menu at all, to see what would happen.
Well, the menu doesn't disappear. It remains. So obviously the menus I am creating and editing are NOT where the website is getting its menu from.
http://i1318.photobucket.com/albums/t658/AcaciaLandscape/Troubleshooting/Menus5_zps218b653b.jpg